Virginia Student Accused Of Sexual Misconduct Claims School District Treats Men Harsher Than Women
WASHINGTON – A Virginia student accused of sexual misconduct claimed that Fairfax County Public Schools treated male students “disproportionately harsher” than female students in sexual harassment cases.
The 18-year-old male student, referred to as “John Doe” in the lawsuit, said the district violated his free speech, due process rights and did not investigate the situation properly. Doe was suspended and sent to a different school, according to the lawsuit given to The Daily Caller News Foundation by attorney Jesse Binnall.
A Robinson Secondary School female accused two male students of sexual harassment after her buttocks were allegedly slapped in December 2018. Surveillance video reportedly showed Doe did not hit the female student, according to the lawsuit.
Doe befriended the female student who was new to the school.
“Doe and Student A had classes together and would see each other at school outside of class,” the lawsuit said. “Doe flirted with Student A, which included friendly conversations, putting his arm around her and playfully poking her in class. Student A did not reject these overtures. In fact, she would often seek out Doe’s company and return his flirtations.”
The female student allegedly “colluded” with her friends to make false statements and the assistant principal was allegedly “seeking evidence that was inculpatory and ignored exculpatory evidence,” according to the lawsuit.
Binnall said to TheDCNF that one of the witnesses changed her story.
“If a male student and female student are both engaged in mutual sexual contact or touching on school grounds, it is common for the male student to be punished and for the female student not to be punished, based on gender,” the lawsuit said.
Doe’s punishment could affect his college wrestling scholarship and entry to a “prestigious” university unless his record gets cleaned by a judge, The Washington Post reported Sunday. A hearing is expected on March 22.
“He was never given a fair shot to make his case to prove that he was innocent in a school district that doesn’t even have a presumption of innocence,” Binnall said to TheDCNF.
John Torre, a spokesman for FCPS, would not comment on the specifics of the case to WaPo, but said the school district “thoroughly investigates all allegations of Title IX violations and takes action, where appropriate.”
Title IX does not allow sex-based discrimination to education programs receiving federal funding. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos proposed sweeping changes to Title IX to clarify students’ rights and schools’ legal obligations in November 2018.
FCPS is dealing with two other federal lawsuits over mishandling of sexual allegation cases, according to WaPo.
The district is the 10th largest in the U.S. and serves more than 187,000 students.
Robinson Secondary principal Matt Eline could not provide comment on the case.
FCPS did not immediately respond to The Daily Caller News Foundation’s request for comment.