Federal Court Upholds Ohio Law Barring State Agencies From Funding Planned Parenthood Ruling Providers Don’t Have Constitutional Right
CINCINNATI – A federal court upheld an Ohio law barring state agencies from funding abortion organizations Tuesday, ruling that abortion providers don’t have a constitutional right to perform abortions.
The United State Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit ruled Tuesday in Planned Parenthood of Greater Ohio et al. v. Hodges to place a permanent injunction on state funds going to support Planned Parenthood.
The ruling upheld a 2016 state law barring its health department from funding organizations that perform, promote, or contract with affiliates that perform or promote non-therapeutic abortions. The court also wrote in its decision that Planned Parenthood doesn’t have a constitutional right to perform abortions.
The court found that while Ohio cannot condition a benefit that requires recipients to sacrifice their constitutional rights, “that condition does not violate the Constitution because the affiliates do not have a due process right to perform abortions,” the decision reads. “The Supreme Court has never identified a freestanding right to perform abortions,” the ruling also states.
FREE DIGITAL SUBSCRIPTION: GET ONLY 'FEATURED' STORIES BY EMAIL
Big Tech is using a content filtering system for online censorship. Watch our short video about NewsGuard to learn how they control the narrative for the Lamestream Media and help keep you in the dark. NewsGuard works with Big-Tech to make it harder for you to find certain content they feel is 'missing context' or stories their editors deem "not in your best interest" - regardless of whether they are true and/or factually accurate. They also work with payment processors and ad-networks to cut off revenue streams to publications they rate poorly by their same bias standards. This should be criminal in America. You can bypass this third-world nonsense by signing up for featured stories by email and get the good stuff delivered right to your inbox.
Tuesday’s decision comes after two Planned Parenthood affiliates sued Ohio over its law barring public funds from supporting the abortion organization, arguing that the law violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments and the Due Process Clause by requiring Planned Parenthood to give up their right to provide abortions in order to receive funding. Planned Parenthood claimed the law indirectly achieved what the state could not directly prohibit.
A district court agreed with Planned Parenthood and permanently enjoined the State from enforcing the 2016 law.
The court found Tuesday, however, that while Planned Parenthood is “correct that the Ohio law imposes a condition on the continued receipt of state funds,” the law does not violate any federal protections because the abortion organization has no constitutional right to perform abortions.
The court also ruled that Ohio’s law doesn’t violate a woman’s right to obtain an abortion. Federal and state law already prohibits public funds from going towards organizations that perform abortions.
Tuesday’s ruling comes after Republican Ohio Gov. John Kasich signed a bill in December banning dilation and evacuation abortions, a common second-trimester abortion method. Kasich vetoed a bill banning abortion upon the presence of a fetal heartbeat in late November after vetoing a similar “heartbeat bill” in 2016.
Planned Parenthood did not immediately respond to The Daily Caller News Foundation’s request for comment.